
8 May 2025 – Time and again, policies in the European Union are underpinned by questionable arguments, figures, and half-truths. In the case of the European Steel and Metals Action Plan and the political campaigns celebrated around it, such as ‘Save our Steel’, it has been shown time and again that the press hardly does any research or asks any critical questions.
Save our Steel: How politics is made with half-truths
With the European Steel and Metals Action Plan, the European Commission, member states and the steel lobby have once again managed to use half-truths and dubious figures to generate demands for subsidies and market protection for supposedly endangered European mills. Unfortunately, the press is also increasingly picking up on such information without scrutinising it critically or carrying out its own research.
For example, a recent article from Politico‘s online offering claims that US tariffs on steel of 25%, which have been in place since 2018, are completely new and that more subsidised steel from other regions of the world is now flowing into the EU market as a result. As already mentioned, the Section 232 tariffs have been in place since 2018 – but they were only revised at the beginning of 2025 and the exceptions contained therein were removed.
Save our Steel: Trump’s tariffs and Chinese overcapacity force governments to act
Steel from the EU is highly subsidised
And while the EU constantly reproaches other countries for their subsidy policies, European steel mills have been highly subsidised for decades, even if the EU has come up with nicer names for them. For example, the EU Emissions Trading System (ETS) with its free allocation of CO2 certificates, whose main beneficiaries are still the domestic mills. The 9 billion euros in ‘state aid’ (= subsidies) for the decarbonisation of outdated and CO2-intensive blast furnaces, which the authors mention a few paragraphs further on, are then gladly ignored.
Mills are already failing to fulfil their voluntary commitment
They also fail to mention that one of the largest steel maker in the EU has actually already cancelled its decarbonisation plans and the associated investment decisions, even though the multinational conglomerate had already received billions in taxpayers’ money for this. Instead of investing in modern and competitive technologies and production methods, it would rather pay out tens of billions to its shareholders.
Commission plans full of contradictions
The plans mentioned by the Commission to reduce energy prices and encourage certain sectors to source more clean steel from Europe instead of buying supposedly dirty steel from abroad also ignore the fact that the Commission wants to subsidise the export of CO2-intensive steel from Europe to the whole world in the future. At the same time, the Commission wants to limit the import of clean steel to Europe, as this would allegedly only be produced for the EU market in order to undermine the Carbon Border Tax CBAM. The contradiction in this Commission proposal should be obvious and clearly bears the signature of the lobbyists.
Figures just made up?
The fact that the Commission then claims that a modern self-propelled artillery system produced in Europe would contain up to 100 tonnes of steel seems rather far-fetched given the combat weight of the German Panzerhaubitze 2000 at just 57 tonnes. Not even the heavily armoured main battle tanks, such as the American M1 Abrams (up to 69 tonnes) or the Leopard 2 (up to 67.5 tonnes) come close.
Latest news
- Is EU steel maker failing to meet its climate targets?
- Stainless steel prices rise in Asia after public holidays
- Germany needs good infrastructure, not mega-factories
We at the Gerber Group have been trading in stainless steel worldwide for over 20 years. We are your experts when it comes to purchasing, import, logistics and services. Information is a vital part of this. Because only then can you and we make the right decisions. Do you have any questions? Contact us now.
Disclaimer: Many things here represent our opinion. Others are information from the Internet. We can therefore never claim to be correct or complete. And never base a business decision solely on the news you receive from us.

