Export taxes on steel and aluminium scrap demanded
Export taxes on steel and aluminium scrap demanded

25 June 2025 – EU steel and aluminium manufacturers have once again called for tighter export restrictions on scrap. But does the call for an export tax on scrap stand up to a fact check? Base metals in Europe and Asia continue to show a stable sideways trend.

Base metals continue to trend sideways

On Wednesday, base metals in Asia and Europe continued to show resilience and moved sideways in a stable manner. Copper, zinc, lead, tin and nickel are trading positively on the LME today. Aluminium remains at a high level, while LME inventories continue to decline.

Base metals also performed well on the SHFE, with nickel (+1.2%) and lead (+1.4%) showing particularly strong price gains.

Export taxes on steel and aluminium scrap demanded

For years, EU steel makers and their lobby group EUROFER have been lobbying for restrictions on the export of steel scrap and other ferrous waste. With the new EU Waste Shipment Regulation, the Union had already made significant concessions to steelworks and restricted scrap exports to OECD countries. Of course, as always, this was not enough for the steel lobbyists. Among other things, OECD member Turkey, as the main buyer of European steel scrap, was exempt from these new rules.

Claim: Section 232 tariffs are intended to favour scrap exports

With the increase in US Section 232 steel and aluminium tariffs from 25% to 50%, the steel lobby now claims that there could be a significant increase in the outflow of steel and aluminium scrap from the European Union to the United States. As media-savvy as ever, they are warning of the allegedly enormous danger this would pose to the green transformation and are immediately calling for the introduction of a European export tax on steel and aluminium scrap.

Fact check: US imports of scrap have fallen significantly in some cases

But is this claim even true? In a fact check, the European steel lobbyists do not come out well. With the introduction of Section 232 tariffs in 2018, there should already have been a significant increase in scrap imports into the United States. However, this has not happened at all. Imports of aluminium scrap into the United States have been on average more than 6% lower since 2018 than in 2017. Imports of steel scrap rose by just under 4% compared to 2017.

Section 232 tariffs have no impact on US scrap imports

A massive increase in scrap imports into the United States, as claimed by domestic steel makers, has thus failed to materialise since the introduction of Section 232 tariffs on steel and aluminium in 2018.

It should also be noted that since 2017, US exports of aluminium scrap have risen by almost 20% and those of steel scrap by more than 12%.

Background: US production capacities severely limited

The reason why a massive increase in scrap imports into the United States is not to be expected is relatively simple. Due to a lack of production capacity, the United States has to cover approximately 50% of its annual aluminium requirements through imports. A similar situation can be observed in steel production – with a theoretical crude steel capacity of approximately 120 million tonnes, the US has only about 56% of the capacity of the EU.

EU steel scrap exports increased for one reason only

The increase in European scrap exports for steel and aluminium can be attributed to a decline in domestic production and thus also to lower demand for scrap. In addition, with a share of just under 55% in crude steel production using the BF-BOF process, the EU has a significantly lower demand for scrap than, for example, the United States, Turkey or India. And we have already proven several times that EU steel makers have preferred to produce less crude steel in recent years in order to trade surplus and free EU CO2 certificates. With the decline in certificate prices, EU steel scrap exports in 2024 were already back at the 2019 level.

Sensational headlines are intended to influence political stakeholders

It can therefore be concluded that there will be no significant increase in the outflow of scrap from the EU to the United States. Once again, sensational headlines and the omission of important information are being used to mislead political stakeholders in the EU member states and in Brussels/Strasbourg.

In the end, it is the small and medium-sized recycling companies in the EU and, ultimately, consumers who will foot the bill for a scrap export tax.

Latest news

Receive all the latest news once a week

Receive all the latest news once a week

Make it easy for yourself: we will remind you once a week about the latest news.

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.

You have Successfully Subscribed!